The 49ers Anti-Starting Lineup
Last season I signed up for text message updates from the 49ers and I have to say, some of the time I'm receiving them before seeing anything online. Being in the slow days of June, not a whole lot is going on so not too many messages. However, early yesterday afternoon I learned that the 49ers had successfully claimed QB Kyle Wright off waivers from the Vikings and waived QB Drew Olson.
Considering the quarterbacks already in camp, I'd be shocked if Wright was on the roster at the end of August. At the same time, Wright could be a prime candidate for the practice squad. Drew Olson actually spent a small part of the season on the practice squad. In the meantime, the claim of Wright has inspired me. The 49ers currently have 81 players on their roster, including unsigned draft picks. Just for sh$#s and giggles I thought I'd put together the "worst starting lineup possible." All of these players are certainly world class athletes, but many of them are not starter quality.
OFFENSE
QB: Kyle Wright - He was ok for the U last season but definitely the worst option.
RB: Michael Robinson - Robinson brings a lot to the table, but I'm convinced Thomas Clayton is a better pure running back. We're not factoring in potential special teams contributions either.
WR: Dominque Ziegler & Jerard Rabb - I actually like most of the 49ers less wide receivers, especially Robert Jordan. Ziegler has struggled with injuries problems and Rabb was the 1A banana at Boise State in 2006 (he was the guy who caught the lateral and tied the game).
TE: Cooper Wallace - At least JJ Finley is a rookie and put up better college numbers. Wallace has been in the NFL a couple years and hasn't made a big impact yet. I'd imagine he's coming to the end of the road pretty soon.
OT: Damane Duckett & Alan Reuber - Duckett is a pet project of Nolan and considering he's never actually played in a game as a tackle. Reuber has been around since 2004 and has seen scattered action during that time.
C: Cody Wallace - Not exactly an inspired pick. I'm tempted to just see Wallace starting over Heitmann, but this is more a default pick since the 49ers only have a pair of centers.
OG: Brian De La Puente & Jeb Terry - Terry has been around the league for a few years and seen some action mostly on special teams. De La Puente is a rookie out of Cal and I wouldn't mind seeing him on the practice squad.
DEFENSE
DE: Atiyyah Ellison & Louis Holmes - Ellison joins the running theme of practice squad bodies on this squad. Louis Holmes is an undrafted free agent, so it's certainly too early to tell what he brings to the table.
DT: Walter Curry - LaJuan Ramsey was battling for this spot, but Ramsey has actually registered real NFL statistics. Curry was an undrafted free agent in 2005 and has bounced from practice squads to NFL Europe and back.
OLB: Roderick Green & Parys Haralson - The linebacker positions show you the deth the 49ers have. Green and Haralson are probably not starting caliber (at least for the 49ers), but they provide quality depth
ILB: Dennis Haley & Larry Grant - As seen in the outside linebackers, inside linebacker would also be a strength of this particular team. Grant is a favorite of mine, so we'll see how he looks in training camp.
CB: Markus Curry & Marcus Hudson - Curry has bounced around practice squads since 2005 and I'd imagine he'd be an early cut in training camp. The second CB spot was tough. Tarell Brown brings way too much upside and Strickland gets a pass thanks to his huge defensive play against the Cardinals. Reggie Smith is too green to be considered here so that leaves "veteran" Marcus Hudson.
FS: Lewis Baker - He's an undrafted free agent with some potential, but I certainly don't see sticking Mark Roman or Dashon Goldson in this spot.
SS: DJ Parker - Similar to Baker above, I don't see sticking Michael Lewis or Keith Lewis in this spot.
There's a back-up punter but that would just be ridiculous to talk about. Of course considering I just did an analysis of the bottom end of the roster pool, maybe I should have included Ricky Schmitt. I'd imagine this team would probably go 0-16. Although, I definitely think this would make for an impressive college team. So, would this team be able to win at the NFL level? Considering we're playing Miami this year, it's entirely possible 1-15 is a better bet.
4 comments | 0 recs
Just for the heck of it: 49ers 2009 free agents
In the Delanie Walker signing post, MM threw out the players who will be free agents after 2009. Obviously a million things will change between now and then and there is little to no way we can predict what will happen at that point. However, it's much more fun randomly speculating about things over which we have absolutely no control. Some are restricted free agents, although I'm not 100% sure about the restricted/unrestricted status of some of them. The entire list is at the bottom, but I thought I'd hit some of the more interesting ones. The 49ers have done a good job lately in signing the young talent to longer deals. On this list, aside from Bryant Johnson, I'm not sure if any of them warrant long term deals for now.
Billy Bajema: Bajema is a blocking tight end who is not exactly what you'd call a pass catcher. Delanie Walker has been impressing Mike Martz, but Bajema brings the blocking element Walker lacks. I don't see Bajema returning when you can probably find a replacement in the draft.
Damane Duckett: While he seems to be a "coach's project," Duckett is an interesting case. It's entirely possible the signing of Barry Sims means Duckett doesn't make the roster this year. Even if he does it will be as a backup and barring injury, I don't know how much of an opportunity he'll get to play behind Joe Staley. Of course I also don't know who else would be interested in a converted defensive lineman who hasn't gotten all that much playing time.
DeShaun Foster: I could definitely see this as a one and done year for Foster. If he can put together a solid year behind a really good running back like Gore, he would definitely get some quality offers. He just needs to show he can stay healthy and be relatively productive. A solid yards per carry could help him cash in.
Bryant Johnson: According to MM, "There is no question Johnson is hungry to prove he's an elite wideout. Johnson said he wants to put together a good season and sign a long-term extension with the 49ers." If Johnson does take a step up and prove himself to be a quality receiver, we'll see how quick he is to sign an extension when teams are throwing piles of money at him.
Eric Heitmann: I'd imagine the 49ers will let him walk. They have some options for the future, which makes Heitmann potentially expendable. Tony Wragge is a restricted free agent and unless somebody was willing to give up picks and a big contract for him, I'd imagine the 49ers could retain him pretty easily. Cody Wallace would seem to be the center of the future, so it's a matter of working him in to the position. Or maybe Heitmann signs a short deal to groom Wallace? No matter what he won't be getting a ton of money from the 49ers.
Ronald Fields: If the 49ers stick with the 3-4, Fields has his work cut out for him if he plans on sticking around. He's a defensive tackle who either needs to improve his game in the middle, or gain some ability and become a defensive end. He hasn't done a whole lot up to this point and the 49ers have brought in some additional young bodies so we'll see how this year plays out.
Ashley Lelie: After spending most of last season in just about everybody's doghouse, Lelie thinks he's learned enough to be able to make some solid contributions in 2008. The 49ers and Mike Martz will need every wide receiver to step up and make things happen. However, unless Lelie blows people away, the 49ers have enough young potential to take their chances with another cheap veteran in free agency who might have a little more upside.
Signed through 2008: TE Billy Bajema, T Damane Duckett, DL Atiyyah Ellison, DL Ronald Fields, RB DeShaun Foster, OLB Roderick Green, C Eric Heitmann, WR Bryant Johnson, FB Zak Keasey, WR Ashley Lelie, QB J.T. O'Sullivan, RS Allen Rossum, CB Donald Strickland, G Tony Wragge.
2 comments | 0 recs







