Niners Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Anquan Boldin Asks Arizona Cardinals for Trade.....Again Bar-right-arrows



Fantasy Football WR - Top 10

Since HowTheyScored is chomping at the bit, I took a few seconds out of my day to start this diary up.  So here it is, your Top 10 WR rankings.

Here's my list which was rushed to be put together and which like my RB list will likely be revisted later.

  1. C. Johnson
  2. S. Smith
  3. R. Wayne
  4. T. Holt
  5. M. Harrison
  6. T. Owens
  7. A. Johnson
  8. L. Evans
  9. R. Williams
  10. J. Walker
So start dumping your lists!

Star-divide

Update [2007-7-9 12:59:22 by Braekneck]: Here are the Top 10 WR average rankings:

  1. C. Johnson
  2. M. Harrison
  3. T. Holt
  4. S. Smith
  5. T. Owens
  6. R. Wayne
  7. A. Johnson
  8. L. Evans
  9. R. Williams
  10. J. Walker
And the honorable mentions are:
  1. M. Colston
  2. L. Fitzgerals
  3. R. Moss
  4. D. Driver

This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of Niners Nation's writers or editors. It does reflect the views of this particular fan though, which is as important as the views of Niners Nation's writers or editors.

0 recs | Comment 14 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

Email
Hey, I tried emailing you as a failed email...Anyways, since you've gotten the ball rolling on this, do you wanna be the point person on the rest of the positional lists?  All that's left is QB, TE and team defense, so maybe once a week or something like that for the rest?  I'm going to eventually get a central page linking to all the diaries, but for now these lists are perfect.
Niners Nation - The premier 49ers blog on the Internet!

by Fooch on Jul 3, 2007 9:56 AM PDT   0 recs

Sure thing
Yeah I can handle putting a diary together for the rest of the positional lists, one per week, probably on Tuesdays.  But where are your RB rankings at?

BTW updated my email.

by methodrampage on Jul 3, 2007 10:08 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

My rankings
Allright, WRs
  1. Chad Johnson
  2. Steve Smith
  3. Marvin Harrison
  4. Torry Holt
  5. Terrell Owens
  6. Reggie Wayne
  7. Javon Walker
  8. Andre Johnson
  9. Lee Evans
  10. Larry Fitzgerald
Merton Hanks forever and ever.

by jtoj on Jul 3, 2007 10:15 AM PDT   0 recs

Oh, excellent
Good stuff. Once again, it'll take me a little bit of time to get something up (maybe tomorrow-abouts) just because there's a lot to consider and I'm a little busy today, but this is a lot of fun.
I keep reliving the moment when Steve Young almost fell down... over and over...

by howtheyscored on Jul 3, 2007 10:16 AM PDT   0 recs

Eyeshield's Top 10 WRs
  1. Marvin Harrison
  2. Terrel Owens
  3. Torry Holt
  4. Chad Johnson
  5. Steve Smith
  6. Marques Colston
  7. Reggie Wayne
  8. Larry Fitzgerald
  9. Roy Williams
  10. Andre Johnson
YAHA!

by Eyeshield21 on Jul 3, 2007 1:14 PM PDT   0 recs

Wow
So, I just couldn't get myself to bring this down to a top 10 list because 1) the competition after the hands down top guys is just so close it doesn't seem fair and, more importantly, 2) most fantasy teams will start two WRs every week, as opposed to one for every other relevant position. So, here goes. I give it my best:

1) Marvin Harrison

He's the only guy in the league year in/year out who is putting up 1200+ yards and double digit TDs, and there's really no reason at all to think that's going to change. I'd be willing to say that not having him #1 is just foolish.

2) Terrell Owens

I really, really hate having Owens this high, especially since he hasn't broken 1200 yards since 2002 and I don't really believe in the Tony Romo experiment, but even if he doesn't get as many yards as a CJ, he's likely to score anwhere from 10-15 TDs, and that's just gold.

3) Torry Holt

Whoo boy does it start to get close even as early as #3. I could see Steve Smith, Terrell Owens, Charles Johnson, Reggie Wayne (ridiculous offense), and even Randy Moss waltzing into this spot. I predict BIG things for Moss, but he's way too much of a wild card to go this high. Smith is only takes it if he returns to his 2005 production, and I think he's still too much of a target for that. Reggie Wayne isn't quite the scorer Holt is. CJ is a major yards guy, but the only time he ever had 10 TDs was 4 yers ago. Holt has shown minor signs of decline that give me pause here, but Bulger will get him the ball, Isaac Bruce isn't going to split touches the way he has in the past, and he's just too darn consistent to predict any kind of decline that isn't pretty minor.

4) Chad Johnson

Chad Johnson and Reggie Wayne and Steve Smith are almost identical here for me. In fact, CJ, RW, SS and Holt are almost identical for me in these four spots in terms of what I expect. I like Holt's chances of going double digit TDs more than any of these guys, and RW playing second fiddle to Marvin Harrison in Indy hurt his chances of putting up the consistent gawdiness of a CJ. Lastly, SS is still all they have in Carolina and I expect something more like '06 than '05. CJ just gets too many yards too consistently. He's just got fewer questions than the rest.

5) Reggie Wayne

Reggie Wayne in Indy's offense, even second to Marvin Harrison, will probably put up comparable numbers to a targeted SS in Carolina's offense, and always has a chance to do better. It's tough to put a #2 guy over Steve Smith, but we make exceptions for guys who catch Peyton Manning.

6) Steve Smith

He's the last of the highly predictable exceptional production guys in terms of all yards, touchdowns, and the guy throwing him the ball. 1-6 on this list are the absolute top tier guys in the league as far as I'm concerned, and it's only process of elimination that makes Smith last among them. But i could see him going anywhere 3-6 and it would make perfect sense to me.

7) Randy Moss

As a prediction, I'd actually have him in the top five if risk had nothing to do with it. His Raider years and his attitude make you seriously wonder if you even want to take the risk, but in my opinion he's Randy Moss catching passes from Tom Brady without anybody breathing down his neck. And even in his off years (last year's debacle aside) he still scored at a pretty exceptional rate. For me, this is an easy pick, but I can see myself getting arguments.

8) Donald Driver

One of a few 1200 yard, 5-10 TD guys. But let's put it this way: This is the difference between catching passes from Brett Favre and catching passes from John Kitna or J. P. Losman. Drivers recent history also gives him a bit of an edge. You just can't fight consistency like this.

9) Roy Williams

Let's just put it this way: this is the differenve between catching passes from John kitna, and catching passes from J. P. Losman.

10) Lee Evans

Bet you could have guessed I was going to say this. He's a very strong pick, but you still kind of have to wonder about Losman throwing to anybody.

11) Larry Fitgerald

I think a full year catching passes from just one QB is going to do LF a lot of good. But he'll still be splitting passes with Boldin, he'll still be cathcing passes from a guy with less than a year of NFL experience behind a suspect line, and he'll still have to average 14 yards a game for once in his career to have significant value over anybody who has come earlier on this list.

12) Marques Colston

I don't know how he's going to respond to his frosh success for his sophomore campaign, but how you can't like Colston in that offense without Joe Horn is beyond me. If not for some serious question I have, he could easily be much higher than this.

13) Reggie Brown

Call me crazy, but it looked like Brown was finally putting it together and getting into a pretty good roll with McNabb last year before Dono went down. He'll be the guy this year, McNabb should be healthy, and in only 46 catches last year he had 8 TDs. Because he's the risk that any third year player who's never caught more than 50 balls or gone for 900 yards in a season has to be considered, I can't blame a single person for keeping well out of the top 15. But I have a really good feeling.

14) Javon Walker

Should be higher than Brown, and should probably be higher than a few more guys, and especially with Cutler's cannon of an arm, but Jay's almost definitely going to struggle and the offense there will be able tc crutch on it's run game in a way that it couldn't last year. I just don't have a good feeling for this particular whiny punk.

15) Anquan Boldin

Always a good bet for solid yards with a chance at spectacular, but he has all the same questions as Larry Fitzgerald regarding the guys around him, will still be splitting those touches, and has had difficulty scoring consistently in the past. If it weren't for the scores, I'd rate him much higher, but he's put himself in this position by not putting himself in the endzone more.

-

Well, there you go. That was tough, but I think my fantasy teams are going to be, well, fantastic because of it.

Enjoy.

I keep reliving the moment when Steve Young almost fell down... over and over...

by howtheyscored on Jul 4, 2007 1:50 PM PDT   0 recs

Wow
There's a lot of Andre Johnson love to go around. I guess I just don't see it.
I keep reliving the moment when Steve Young almost fell down... over and over...

by howtheyscored on Jul 4, 2007 2:27 PM PDT   0 recs

103 Receptions
Andre Johnson is hands down the go-to-guy in Houston's offense.  He had his 2nd 1000+ yard recieving season last year and 103 receptions despite having David Carr as a QB.  With Schaub as the QB its concievable that Johnson's production will increase.

by methodrampage on Jul 5, 2007 7:17 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

I don't know
I guess it comes down to how you feel about Schaub behind that line, because Johnson's barely averaged 11 yards a catch the last two years and has never caught more than 6 TDs in a single season. It's easy to blame that on Carr and believe that Schaub is going to make the difference, but... I'm not much of a believer in Schaub and I'm not so sure a guy with 103 receptions and only 5 scores to go with it isn't maybe a big part of the problem himself.

But mostly I think it's just that I think Schaub is pretty darned overrated, and the effect on Johnson won't be worth much.

I keep reliving the moment when Steve Young almost fell down... over and over...

by howtheyscored on Jul 5, 2007 10:47 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Yards per Catch
What does yards per catch really mean?

Johnson had a lack-luster '05 but his rookie and sophmore seasons were impressive, where he averaged 14+ yards per catch.  But I'd take a guy that catches 103 passes while averaging 11 yards per catch over a guy who only catches 42 passes but averages 18 yards per catch any day.  A first down is only 10 yards anyways.

So you're saying that Johnson just can't catch passes in the end zone?

David Carr only threw 11 TDs last year, Johnson had 5 and Houston's TE Owen Daniels had 5.  So somebody else caught the other one.  I don't think I'd blame Johnson on the lack of TDs.  Houston just wasn't throwing many TD to begin with.

But my biggest reason for ranking as high as I did is I play in PPR (points per reception) leagues and catching 103 passes is really solid in that kind of scoring system.

by methodrampage on Jul 5, 2007 1:13 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Well
I tend to think of yards per reception as a minor predictive tool, at least of somebody wth big play ability or the potential for a breakout year.

It is obvious that a lot of Johnson's problems getting into the endzone come as a byproduct of the offense he plays in and the performance of David Carr. Even in his first two years he wasn't scoring a lot, though, so I do wonder a little about his redzone potential. And I just don't think that Schaub is much of an improvement over Carr, and the rest of the offense has barely improved, if at all. He is extremely likely to make anywhere between 80-100 catches (with a reasonable margin of error), but I don't see any reason other than Schaub to believe that any of his other stats are going to see any improvement.

So I still think that it has a lot to do with what you think of Matt Schaub over David Carr, though he does have considerably more value in a reception counting league, especially because he's all they have out there (a kind of league I wasn't thinking of in my top 15 list).

But I'm not trying to say that Andre Johnson doesn't have the ability because of his ypc or his TDs the last two years (though I do wonder about his redzoniness a little, just that I don't see any reason that the offense will allow him to do any better.

I keep reliving the moment when Steve Young almost fell down... over and over...

by howtheyscored on Jul 5, 2007 4:16 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Fair Enough
I'm in the party that doesn't think Andre Johnson has reached his potential and Houston's brass though a hell of a lot more about Schaub than they did Carr.  But only time will tell.

by methodrampage on Jul 6, 2007 7:08 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Diary Updated
Diary has been updated with the average rankings.  Everybodies top 5 were very similar, but the bottom 5 varied quite a bit.

Expect a QB ranking list tomorrow.

by methodrampage on Jul 9, 2007 10:01 AM PDT   0 recs

I guess
There wasn't as much participation in this one as the RB one, but it's still kind of cool to see that I singlehandedly got Randy Moss into the honorable mentions.
I keep reliving the moment when Steve Young almost fell down... over and over...

by howtheyscored on Jul 9, 2007 11:58 AM PDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Where Josh Morgan fever is reaching unhealthy levels!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Img_0827_2_small
Is there a power struggle in SF??
Dixon_small
My All-Time 49ers Team
Small
Double Whammy
Small
unsigned WR with massive potentential that no one is talking about
S
O' Boy
Dixon_small
Colvin?
Dixon_small
New Here
Ab_small
Shaun Hill?
Small
Niners Nation Madden League Interest
Small
The Quarterback 3-Way Battle, or Is It?

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Head Ball Coach

Dave_small Fooch

Assistant Coaches

Untitled_small howtheyscored

Mattforweb_small MattMiller

ad

Site Meter